Square vs SumUp vs Clover for a Small Shop

Card rates, hardware costs, and the contract traps that matter for a one-location counter doing $5,000 to $40,000 a month. Prices come from Square’s, SumUp’s, and Clover’s official pricing pages as of November 2026. Confirm current numbers before you sign anything.

The short verdict

Under about $40,000 a month in card sales, the processing gap between these three is a few dollars to a few tens of dollars a month. The bigger differences are hardware, inventory features, and how hard it is to leave.

Disclosure: If this site later uses affiliate links, those links will be marked, and the site may earn a commission. This comparison is based on publicly listed features, pricing, and help documentation, not on a paid placement. We did not run a shop on any of these systems for this article.

What each one costs (as of November 2026)

Every card setup has three cost layers: the monthly software fee, the per-payment rate, and hardware. A fourth, easy to miss, is getting your money fast. All three charge for instant payouts.

Square SumUp Clover (Clover.com pricing)
Free or entry plan Square Free, $0/month Standard, $0/month Starter, $0/month software, sold with the Compact terminal
In-person card rate, entry plan 2.6% + 15¢ 2.6% + 10¢ 2.6% + 10¢
Keyed-in or card-on-file rate 3.5% + 15¢ 3.5% + 15¢ (online or manual entry) 3.5% + 10¢ (typed in)
Online rate 3.3% + 30¢ (Free); 2.9% + 30¢ (Plus) 3.5% + 15¢ Not separately listed on the retail page
Paid plan for a shop Plus $49/month (2.5% + 15¢); Premium $149/month (2.4% + 15¢) POS Plus $49/month; SumUp POS from $99/month (same card rates) Retail Growth $84.95/month (2.3% + 10¢)
Cheapest hardware Reader $59 (needs phone or tablet) Plus reader (needs phone or tablet; see note below); Solo $99 standalone Compact $349, or $16/month for 36 months
Counter setup Square Register $899, Terminal $299, Stand $149 (plus an iPad) SumUp Terminal (listed at $249, on promotion when we checked) Station Duo bundle: $1,899 plus $84.95/month software, or $180/month for 36 months
Payout speed Free next business day; instant or same-day 1.95% Next-day payouts on all plans Rapid Deposit 1.75% for funds within minutes
Contract None; cancel or switch anytime, per Square No long-term commitment on POS Plus; no monthly minimums 36-month hardware subscriptions are non-cancelable; termination terms vary by seller

Two notes. SumUp’s reader page showed promotional prices when we checked (the Terminal at $174, down from $249, and the Plus reader marked down from $54, though its fine print listed a different original price). Budget on list price. And Clover’s prices above are Clover.com prices. Clover is also sold through banks and other partners, and Clover says terms and fees vary by seller.

What a month actually costs at three sales levels

Here is in-person card processing plus software, using each company’s advertised rates. These are estimates. They leave out hardware, refunds, instant payouts, and keyed-in sales, and they assume every sale is a tapped or inserted card.

Monthly card sales (average ticket) Square Free Square Plus SumUp Standard Clover Starter (Compact) Clover Retail Growth
$5,000 (200 sales at $25) $160 $204 $150 $150 $220
$15,000 (500 sales at $30) $465 $499 $440 $440 $480
$40,000 (1,000 sales at $40) $1,190 $1,199 $1,140 $1,140 $1,105

How the math works: Square Free at $15,000 is 2.6% ($390) plus 500 × 15¢ ($75). SumUp and Clover Starter charge the same 2.6% but only 10¢ per sale, so they come out $10 to $50 cheaper here. Clover Retail Growth’s 2.3% rate only pulls ahead around $40,000 a month, before its $1,899 hardware bundle.

Square Plus is rarely worth it for the rate cut alone. A 0.1-point discount saves $15 a month at $15,000 in sales, against a $49 fee. Plus pays for itself through its inventory, purchasing, and staff tools, not the rate.

The lock-in question

This is where the three really differ.

Square says on its pricing page: no locked-in contracts, cancel or switch anytime. You buy hardware outright (or finance it at 15% APR, per Square’s fine print), and Square lists free 30-day returns.

SumUp says POS Plus has no long-term commitments and can be canceled anytime, and its standard plan has no monthly fee or minimums. Readers carry a 30-day money-back guarantee and a one-year warranty.

Clover is the one to read carefully. Clover’s own pricing FAQ says its device subscriptions are non-cancelable and ineligible for refunds, though they can be paid off, upgraded, or bought out. If you do nothing at the end of the term, the subscription continues month to month at the same charge until you give 30 days’ notice. Clover also says devices bought or leased from anyone cannot be used with other payment processors, and that contract terms and termination fees vary by who sold you the system. If a bank or reseller offers you Clover, ask for the processing rates, the monthly software fee, the hardware terms, and any early termination fee in writing before you sign.

What you get for inventory and a real checkout

For a shop with more than a handful of products, the processing rate matters less than whether the POS can run the floor.

Who should pick which

Square is the right call if:

SumUp is the right call if:

Clover is the right call if:

Not sure yet: start on Square Free or SumUp Standard with a cheap reader. Neither has a contract, so you can run a month of real sales, check your average ticket and card mix, and redo the math with your own numbers.

Frequently asked questions

Which is cheapest: Square, SumUp, or Clover?

On processing alone, SumUp and Clover’s Starter plan tie at 2.6% + 10¢ per in-person card, slightly under Square Free’s 2.6% + 15¢. The gap is 5¢ per sale, about $25 a month at 500 sales. Clover’s hardware costs more, though, and Square’s free plan includes more retail features. At about $40,000 a month and up, Clover Retail Growth’s 2.3% rate can come out ahead, before hardware.

Is SumUp really free?

The standard plan has no monthly fee, no minimums, and no hardware rental. You buy a reader once and pay 2.6% + 10¢ per in-person card payment and 3.5% + 15¢ for online or keyed-in payments. POS Plus ($49 a month) and SumUp POS (from $99 a month) are optional.

Can I cancel Clover?

Clover’s own FAQ says hardware subscriptions are non-cancelable, though you can pay them off or upgrade. Software and processing terms, including any early termination fee, depend on who sold you the system: Clover directly, a bank, or a reseller. Get them in writing.

Can I use my Clover device with a different processor?

No. Clover says its POS devices, whether bought or leased, cannot be used with other payment processors. Factor that into the hardware price: a $1,899 bundle is only worth it if you plan to stay with Clover’s processing.

How fast do I get paid?

Square sends free transfers as soon as the next business day, or instantly for 1.95%. SumUp advertises next-day payouts on every plan. Clover offers Rapid Deposit, with funds within minutes, for 1.75%. We could not confirm Clover’s standard free deposit timing on its pricing pages.

Related guides

Sources