Homebase vs When I Work vs 7shifts: Scheduling for a Small Shop
Which employee scheduling and time clock app fits a one-location retail shop or small service business, what each costs as of November 2026, and the headcount where the math flips. Prices come from each company’s official pricing page. Confirm current numbers before you sign up.
The short verdict
- Most single-location shops should start with Homebase. Its free Basic plan covers one location with up to 10 employees and includes a time clock. Past that, Essentials is a flat $30 a month per location ($24 a month billed annually) no matter how many people you schedule.
- Pick When I Work if you want per-user pricing for a small crew across more than one location, or its auto-scheduling and forecasting tools on the cheapest plan. It starts at $2.50 per user per month, but there is no free plan, and the time clock is a separate toggle that raises the rate.
- Pick 7shifts only if you run a café, bakery, or other food-service counter. It is built for restaurants (tips, kitchen roles, restaurant POS). Its free Comp plan covers up to 15 employees at one location, but has no time clock.
Disclosure: If this site later uses affiliate links, those links will be marked, and the site may earn a commission. This comparison is based on publicly listed features and pricing, not on a paid placement. We did not run a shop’s schedule in these apps for this article.
What each plan costs (as of November 2026)
The biggest difference is not the sticker price. It is the pricing model. Homebase and 7shifts charge per location. When I Work charges per user. That single fact decides most comparisons for a shop with 5 to 25 people on the schedule.
Homebase (per location, per month):
| Plan | Monthly billing | Annual billing | Who it fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $0 | $0 | 1 location, up to 10 employees. Basic scheduling, basic time tracking, POS integration. |
| Essentials | $30 | $24 | Unlimited employees. Advanced scheduling and time tracking, team messaging. |
| Plus | $70 | $56 | Adds PTO and time-off controls, departments and permissions, AI scheduling assistant. |
| All-in-One | $120 | $96 | Adds onboarding, HR and compliance tools. |
Add-ons: payroll is $49 a month plus $6 per employee paid (Homebase was advertising the first 6 months free, and lists a $29-a-month option for teams up to 5). Tip Manager is $25 a month per location. Task Manager is $13 a month per location. A 14-day All-in-One trial needs no card and drops to Basic when it ends.
When I Work (per user, per month):
| Plan | Scheduling price | Adds |
|---|---|---|
| Essentials | $2.50/user | Auto scheduling, templates, forecast tools, team messaging, open shifts and swaps, payroll and POS integrations |
| Pro | $5/user | Scheduling rules, role permissions, labor sharing, custom reporting |
| Premium | $8/user | API access, webhooks, single sign-on |
Each plan card on When I Work’s pricing page has a "Time Tracking & Attendance" toggle that raises the per-user price. Independent price trackers that read the page in fall 2026 report the toggled rates as $4, $7, and $10 per user. If you need employees to clock in, budget on those numbers and confirm them in the trial. The page lists a 14-day free trial and no free plan.
7shifts (per location, per month):
| Plan | Monthly billing | Annual billing | Limits and key features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Comp | $0 | $0 | 1 location, up to 15 employees. Basic scheduling, announcements, availability and time-off requests. No time clock. |
| Essentials | $44.99 | $39.99 | Up to 30 employees. Adds basic time clocking, team messaging, permissions. |
| Pro | $89.99 | $79.99 | Adds labor compliance and labor cost tools. |
| Premium | $149.99 | $134.99 | Adds tip and task management. |
What a real crew costs per month
Here is the monthly bill at one location, on monthly billing, for scheduling with a time clock (the setup most shops actually need):
| Team size | Homebase | When I Work Essentials (with time tracking, about $4/user) | 7shifts |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6 people | $0 (Basic) | about $24 | $44.99 (Essentials) |
| 10 people | $0 (Basic) | about $40 | $44.99 (Essentials) |
| 14 people | $30 (Essentials) | about $56 | $44.99 (Essentials) |
| 25 people | $30 (Essentials) | about $100 | $44.99 (Essentials, up to 30 people) |
If you only need a schedule and no time clock, When I Work Essentials is $2.50 per user, which beats Homebase Essentials’ flat $30 up to 12 people. 7shifts Comp is $0 up to 15 people with no clock.
The pattern is simple. Up to 10 people at one location, Homebase Basic is hard to beat because it is free and includes a clock. Above 10, Homebase’s flat fee beats per-user pricing quickly. When I Work only gets cheaper when the crew is very small and you would be paying Homebase anyway, for example a second location.
Criteria that actually change the outcome
Time clock and payroll handoff. For an hourly team, the schedule is half the job; clean timesheets are the other half. Homebase includes a basic clock on the free plan and connects timesheets to its own payroll add-on. When I Work sells the clock as a toggle and integrates with outside payroll. 7shifts adds clocking on Essentials. Decide where payroll will run first, then pick the scheduler that hands it clean hours.
POS integration. All three list POS integrations. Homebase includes it even on Basic, and its clock can run on POS devices. Before you commit, check that your specific POS (Square, Clover, Shopify, or other) appears on the vendor’s integrations page and what it syncs: sales for labor percentage, tips, or just employee lists.
Permissions. A shop with a keyholder or assistant manager needs someone besides the owner to edit the schedule. Homebase puts departments and permissions on Plus ($70). When I Work puts role permissions on Pro ($5 per user). 7shifts lists customizable permissions on Essentials.
Labor-law features. Some cities and states have predictive scheduling, break, or overtime rules. All three sell compliance-related features on higher tiers. If you are in a city with scheduling rules, check what each plan actually enforces before you rely on it.
Retail fit. Homebase and When I Work are general-purpose tools for hourly teams: retail, service, and food. 7shifts is restaurant software. Its tip pooling and food-service features are wasted on a gift shop or salon.
Who should pick which
Homebase fits:
- One location with 10 or fewer employees who need a schedule and a time clock (free).
- One location with more than 10 people (flat $30, or $24 billed annually).
- Owners who want scheduling, timesheets, and payroll in one place.
When I Work fits:
- Two or three small locations, each with a handful of staff, where per-user pricing beats paying per location.
- Teams that want auto scheduling and forecasting on the entry plan.
- Shops already running payroll elsewhere (Gusto, ADP, or the accounting system’s payroll) that just need clean exports.
7shifts fits:
- Cafés, bakeries, juice bars, and food counters that pool tips.
- Food businesses with up to 15 people that only need a shared schedule (free Comp plan).
Skip all three if the POS you already pay for has scheduling and time tracking that are good enough. Some POS systems, Square among them, offer their own staff tools, and a second app is only worth it if it fixes a real problem.
Frequently asked questions
Is Homebase really free?
Yes, the Basic plan is $0 for one location with up to 10 employees, and includes basic scheduling, basic time tracking, and POS integration. Paid features start at $30 a month per location (Essentials). Payroll, Tip Manager, and Task Manager are separate add-ons.
Does When I Work have a free plan?
Not as of November 2026. Its pricing page lists a 14-day free trial, then paid plans from $2.50 per user per month. Adding time tracking and attendance raises the per-user price.
Can retail shops use 7shifts?
You can, but it is built for restaurants. A retail shop pays for food-service features it will not use. Homebase or When I Work is usually a better fit.
Which is cheapest for a shop with 15 employees?
With a time clock, Homebase Essentials at $30 a month per location ($24 billed annually). When I Work Essentials with time tracking would be about $60, and 7shifts Essentials is $44.99. Without a clock, 7shifts Comp is free up to 15 employees.
Do these apps run payroll?
Homebase sells payroll as an add-on ($49 a month plus $6 per employee paid). 7shifts also offers payroll. When I Work integrates with outside payroll providers and promotes a Rippling partnership. If you use accounting software with payroll (for example Wave or QuickBooks), compare that cost too. Our Wave vs QuickBooks guide lists both.
How long does it take to switch schedulers?
Plan on a full pay period running both. Load employees and availability, publish two weeks of schedules in the new app, have staff clock in on it, and compare the timesheets to the old system before you cut over.
Related guides
- Wave vs QuickBooks Online for a Small Shop
- Square vs Shopify POS for a One-Location Specialty Shop
- All guides